PDA

View Full Version : High thumb


raubvogel
October 14, 2017, 08:30
Why is the guy on the front of the picture with his thumb way high on the revolver?
http://pics.livejournal.com/larvatus/pic/002wdze8

TenTea
October 14, 2017, 08:41
Looks like he is about to make a shot after cocking for single action...?
May have just cocked it when the shutter snapped...?
3rd guy is doing the same thing.

Bawana jim
October 14, 2017, 12:21
Don't know for sure but they did have training from a barricade stance where the thumb was used against the wall to steady the shot. The thumb was not part of the grip but pushed against the wall.

Wildcat
October 14, 2017, 20:54
Some people push against the left side recoil shield to better control the revolver in recoil.
In this case it may simply be the most consistent spot to apply the thumb. I'd guess he gets very repeatable hand placement on the grip with that hold.

hueyville
October 15, 2017, 18:17
Six men in same uniforms with same equipment all with variations in gripping their gun. Inconsistent training with no "standard". #1 and #3 both have thumb resting high on cylinder as drop the hammer. #1 is shooting both eyes open and #3 is shooting right handed but left eye dominant. #2, #4 and #5 all have same low thumb grip but #4 is a southpaw. #2 appears to be shooting left eye closed and the southpaw #4 appears to be both eyes open (guessing as seems weak eye is open so assume dominant is as well). Hard to be sure but #5 seems to be both eyes open. #6 is pretty much obscured but down the line looks live varience in stance with some straight forward leg, some with knee slightly bent, #2 has feet closer together than rest with relaxed stance and #1 can't see his legs. #2 and #3 are almost facing forward with hips and midsection, #5 and #6 are almost totally sideways.

Most of the schools have been too instructor would be all over the group and stopping live fire till got everyone's stance consistent to style of teaching, grip standardized and both eyes open. Instructors usually have a stance, hold and head/eye technique they prefer students to use. Have spent two days learning to shoot a way I didn't like but on occasion would adapt a part of what was taught and modify my stance. One thing have seen almost every instructor bust people on is thumbing the frame/slide/cylinder. Last person I ran through my class was thumbing his handguns terribly so stopped him, ran 30 minutes of dry fire staying on him every time his thumb tried to go back to touching side of gun and hammering him on stance. He was exerting different pressure on each gun based on its size and shape plus the more a gun recoiled, more he leaned to rear instead of into the hard hitters.

Right wrong or indifferent, accuracy comes from consistency. When went back to live rounds his groups had closed three to four inches on average which stunned him. Initially at 25 feet could not keep full magazine or cylinder in A and C area of regulation IPSC target. Had shots wide and low in D area plus high into B. Even had a few misses with his little polymer Ruger 380 pocket pistol. An hour into time at firing line he was keeping all shots with all guns in A/C with many more A's than when begun. Took three weeks to unlearn him before able to properly lay a good foundation. Inside of two months he was one of my go-to guys for backup in security environment.

Andy the Aussie
October 15, 2017, 23:17
Early image of GIGN I suspect. They were/are fairly well known for being able to hit what they aim at with those MR73s.

yellowhand
October 16, 2017, 01:28
Six men in same uniforms with same equipment all with variations in gripping their gun. Inconsistent training with no "standard". #1 and #3 both have thumb resting high on cylinder as drop the hammer. #1 is shooting both eyes open and #3 is shooting right handed but left eye dominant. #2, #4 and #5 all have same low thumb grip but #4 is a southpaw. #2 appears to be shooting left eye closed and the southpaw #4 appears to be both eyes open (guessing as seems weak eye is open so assume dominant is as well). Hard to be sure but #5 seems to be both eyes open. #6 is pretty much obscured but down the line looks live varience in stance with some straight forward leg, some with knee slightly bent, #2 has feet closer together than rest with relaxed stance and #1 can't see his legs. #2 and #3 are almost facing forward with hips and midsection, #5 and #6 are almost totally sideways.

Most of the schools have been too instructor would be all over the group and stopping live fire till got everyone's stance consistent to style of teaching, grip standardized and both eyes open. Instructors usually have a stance, hold and head/eye technique they prefer students to use. Have spent two days learning to shoot a way I didn't like but on occasion would adapt a part of what was taught and modify my stance. One thing have seen almost every instructor bust people on is thumbing the frame/slide/cylinder. Last person I ran through my class was thumbing his handguns terribly so stopped him, ran 30 minutes of dry fire staying on him every time his thumb tried to go back to touching side of gun and hammering him on stance. He was exerting different pressure on each gun based on its size and shape plus the more a gun recoiled, more he leaned to rear instead of into the hard hitters.

Right wrong or indifferent, accuracy comes from consistency. When went back to live rounds his groups had closed three to four inches on average which stunned him. Initially at 25 feet could not keep full magazine or cylinder in A and C area of regulation IPSC target. Had shots wide and low in D area plus high into B. Even had a few misses with his little polymer Ruger 380 pocket pistol. An hour into time at firing line he was keeping all shots with all guns in A/C with many more A's than when begun. Took three weeks to unlearn him before able to properly lay a good foundation. Inside of two months he was one of my go-to guys for backup in security environment.

Normal rules do not apply for folks on these teams Huey, so long as they can drop a hammer each and every time on a human target without hesitation and hit said target, no one gets excited about any variations in individual technique.

yellowhand
October 16, 2017, 01:34
Early image of GIGN I suspect. They were/are fairly well known for being able to hit what they aim at with those MR73s.

Yes they were,;)

Andy the Aussie
October 16, 2017, 14:10
The officer in the foreground is Squadron Leader (then Lieutenant) Prouteau, the founding OIC of GIGN.