How much

[mr fixit]

I'm thinking of a new 1911 build. I'm planning on an Officers frame, and Commander top.

Wondering if you folks can tell me from experience how much different an aluminum frame versus a steel frame feels while carrying it IWB.

Is the extra cost of the Alum. frame worth the savings in weight?

Mr Fixit

[legion489]

Having had both, yes the aluminum frame IS much lighter and easier to carry. The steel frame will last much longer if shot alot, but how many people actually shoot their guns enough to matter?

[bykerhd]

Longevity has always been the strike against aluminum 1911 frames.
But, for real world, shot seldom, carried a lot use, the aluminum frame will probably hold up just fine.
Unless you are planning a lot of practice with HOT loads.
In which case, steel will probably give you better service.

The total weight savings on the frame will be just a few ounces.
Choose the rest of the components carefully to maintain any real weight savings. Also, remember that the lighter the pistol, the worse the recoil is likely to seem.

[FAL GRUNT]

For me the extra weight savings is worth the extra money. I don't have one, but I plan on building one here this fall. My problem will be as both above posters mentioned, round count and durability.

I shoot, if able, 50 plus or minus rounds a week out of my 45. So a steel frame is necessary for me for practice. Also, I like to shoot 3-gun and at the last match I shot I went through 150 or so rounds. Again, steel is necessary.

However, I want to build a .45 similar to what you intend, my 5" full frame 1911 really bugs me after a few hours of carrying. Being that I am 6'1" and 130 pounds doesn't help.

The other downside to aluminum is the difficulty modifying it after you have received the finished product. Alot of gunsmiths I know like to stipple, round edges, polish, etc, which with steel is easy, and you can dunk it in the bluing or parking tanks when done. With aluminum you have to send it out to be anodized.

HTH, let us know what you decide and be sure to post PICTURES of your final product.

-myers

[mr fixit]

Here is what the hang up is:

Caspian carbon or stainless : $190 +ship +transfer
Fusion Alum. Alloy : $230 +ship +transfer +send off to refinish if needed after 'smithing

Or Caspian Stainless from an acquaintance that bought it and never built it
New/Used Caspian SS : $150

So if I replace my Glock 26 with whatever I build (which I want to) I worry how heavier much that SS officer/commander will feel.

Honestly, I'm leaning toward the SS for $150.


Mr Fixit

[Artful]

Originally posted by mr fixit
Here is what the hang up is:

Or Caspian Stainless from an acquaintance that bought it and never built it
New/Used Caspian SS : $150

Honestly, I'm leaning toward the SS for $150.

Mr Fixit

I wouldn't be leaning, I'd be jumpting...;)

[fire for effect]

A .45 is not supose to be comfortable, it meant to be comforting.